Day After: Coalition Scenarios Revised

It’s 8 am Bratislava time and true to the promise of the Central Electoral Commission, all precincts are in.  Here is the new parliament:

Slovak_election_data_2006_revision10

There will be plenty of time in the next few days to discuss why this differed so significantly from what I supposed.  At present, I will focus briefly on what this portends.  First, the absence of KSS and SF greatly simplifies the set of coalition relationships, reducing the total number of possibilities from 256 to 64.

Coalition_permutations6

Of these, furthermore at least one is virtually unthinkable (SNS-SMK/MKP).  Many of the other "excluded relationships" involved SF or KSS, so other combinations are at least within the realm of possibility (though several parties have excluded the option of working with HZDS as long as Meciar remained at its head, and Meciar has made statements about his unwillingness to work with SNS chair Slota).

Of the 64 possible coalitions, 12 can be excluded because they contain SNS and SMK/MKP, 28 others do not muster a parliamentary majority, and 16 are larger than necessary for a majority.  (SME makes a muddle of this on its own page: http://evolby.sme.sk/c/2767865/Vysledky-parlamentnych-volieb-2006.html
This leaves 8 possible coalition combinations which, because I think in graphic terms, I array below.  Among the possibilities, the most talked about are the first four:

Coalition_permutations2_page_4


Coalition_permutations2_page_6


Coalition_permutations2_page_3


Coalition_permutations2_page_5

Four others are less likely but still possible:

  Coalition_permutations5a_page_2

Using the data from a previous assessment, it is possible to gauge the internal antipathy of various members, at least at the mass level.  This may mean nothing, however, at the elite level when it comes time to making a bargain to form a government.

Coalition # Seats Weak-
est Link
Avg.
Anti-
pathy
3 Party: Smer+Oppo
(HZDS/SNS)
85 -27 -16
2 Party: Smer+SDKU 81 -65 -65
3 Party: Smer+Mix
(KDH/SNS)
84 -69 -42
3 Party: Smer+Coal
(SMK/KDH)
84 -69 -49
3 Party: Smer+Mix
(HZDS/KDH)
79 -69 -54
4 Party: No Smer Mix
(HZDS/KDH/SNS/SDKU)
80 -83 -49
4 Party: No Smer Mix
(HZDS/KDH/SMK/SDKU)
80 -90 -45
3 Party: Smer+Mix (HZDS/SMK) 80 -90 -58

So now the fun begins.

Leave a Reply